Designing flexibility into complex module transportation

Case

When transporting some of the largest modules for Yinson Production’s AGOGO FPSO project, the challenge was not simply their sheer size. Vessel selection remained open, module loads varied significantly and project conditions continued to change, meaning the engineering could not be built around one fixed transport setup.

Blue Water was appointed to transport 15 topside modules for Yinson Production’s AGOGO FPSO project. The modules were transported from fabrication yards in Asia as part of five shipments, with the heaviest module weighing approximately 2,800 tonnes. One of the main engineering challenges emerged before the modules ever moved: the vessels had not yet been selected.

Availability, cost and timing all played a role in vessel selection, while each vessel also had to meet several technical requirements. Deck capacity, water depth, tidal conditions and ballast capacity all had to be considered, including whether the vessel could maintain a level position with the jetty during the RoRo operation.

The engineering could therefore not be built around one specific vessel.

Designing for more than one vessel

The team carried out feasibility studies for multiple vessels while developing a grillage system designed to transfer the forces from the modules safely to the vessel deck. The system was designed with flexibility in mind, allowing the same basic design to be used across different vessels and adapted to modules with different weights and load conditions. It was also designed to simplify installation and reduce the amount of material and time required for sea-fastening.

The solution also had to account for significant differences in how forces from the modules would be transferred to the vessel. Loads from a single module across the individual grillages could vary from 50 to 540 tonnes, meaning the forces were far from evenly distributed across the cargo footprint. The team therefore had to analyse how those loads would transfer through the grillage system and into the vessel deck. By considering these conditions early, the engineering team could develop a solution that supported vessel selection while keeping the operation as simple and cost-efficient as possible.

Built to adapt when conditions changed

The flexibility built into the grillage system became particularly important as the project progressed. A late vessel change required the team to revise the technical documentation, while changes to module weights and centres of gravity required additional grillage capacity.

The original conditions had changed, but the engineering did not have to start from scratch.

The grillage system had been designed so its capacity could be upgraded when required, allowing the team to adapt the existing solution. Other challenges also emerged during execution. When the vessel pumps did not perform as planned, the team implemented a contingency solution using ramps and mats to raise the vessel deck and steel plates to enable the roll-on operation. Deflections in the module transport frames also required extensive shimming work during the loading operations.

For Subrata Podder, Marine & Transport Engineering Manager at Blue Water TEC, early involvement was an important part of being able to respond when project conditions changed.

“Early involvement is crucial in projects like this. It gives us time to understand the operation before the transport solution is fixed and design for some of the changes that may come later. In this case, that flexibility became very important as the project developed,” says Subrata Podder, Marine & Transport Engineering Manager at Blue Water TEC.

Engineering connected to execution

The engineering scope extended well beyond the grillage design itself. Across the five shipments, the team supported feasibility, deck strength calculations, mooring and ballast analysis, sea-fastening, motion analysis and route planning.

The team also supported the loading operations on site, coordinating closely with the client-appointed SPMT operator and the crews responsible for mooring, ballasting, rigging and welding. During the RoRo operations, SPMTs moved the modules to the vessel, across the RoRo ramp and onto the vessel deck, where they were positioned over the grillage for jack-down and shimming.

This close connection between engineering and execution meant that decisions made during the design phase could reflect the practical realities of the operation. Vessel selection affected the grillage design, module loads affected deck strength calculations, and jetty and tidal conditions affected ballast and mooring arrangements. With engineers also supporting the project on site, the technical assumptions made during planning could be checked against the conditions encountered during loading. For Yinson Production, this provided continuity from engineering and planning through to the transport operations themselves.

The Agogo project demonstrates that good planning is not about predicting every change or obstacle. It is about understanding the operation well enough to develop a solution that can adapt when conditions change.

About Yinson Production

Yinson Production is a market leader, providing pioneering excellence in FPSO Solutions, ensuring reliability, efficiency and profitability for all stakeholders. Yinson Production specialises in the provision of integrated services for Floating Production, Storage, Offloading (FPSO) and Floating Storage and offloading (FSO) units.